Annual meeting
All members of the Division can attend the meeting via Zoom Monday, July 29, 2024 at 1 p.m. Central.
CLICK HERE for the Zoom meeting.
All members received the ID and passcode via email. If you did not receive it, contact any of the Division officers.
AGENDA
- National meeting in Philadelphia
- Membership
- Bylaw update
- Budget
- Use of Community
- Goals for 2024-2025
Scholastic Journalism Division Annual Report
OFFICERS
- Bradley Wilson, division head, Midwestern State University
- R. J. Morgan, vice head/Teach-in chair, University of Mississippi
- Kim Lauffer, secretary, Keene State College
- Theresa de los Santos, research chair, Pepperdine University
- David W. Bulla, PF&R chair, Augusta University
- Elizabeth Smith, teaching chair, Pepperdine University
- Sarah Cavanah, newsletter chair, Southeast Missouri State University (now at University of Kansas)
- Melanie Wilderman, web/community chair, University of Oklahoma
- Calvin L. Hall, Commission on the Status of Minorities liaison, North Carolina Central University
- Marina Hendricks, Commission on the Status of Women liaison, South Dakota State University
- Erica Salkin, Archivist, Whitworth University
OVERALL ACTIVITIES
With new officers, this was a transition year. No leader could be as efficient or productive as Marina Hendricks and she was willing to help any time we asked her.
Moving to Community proved to be a challenge. We lost a lot of historical information from our old site. Community is not attractive and is cumbersome to update. However, we were able to get our awards notification out sooner than in past years and able to announce award recipients in time to get them published in fall conference program and online/social media before the end of the academic year.
Teaching is integral to the Scholastic Journalism Division’s mission, which makes us a sought-after co-sponsor for conference programming. We continued our efforts to raise our AEJMC profile in this area by forging new partnerships and seeking new opportunities.
GOALS
For the upcoming year
- To have a monthly virtual meeting of the Division and Division leadership beginning in August.
- To update our Division’s mission and choose a name that reflects that mission — if any change is required.
- To revise the Division’s bylaws including examining our leadership structure to identify new roles and update (or discontinue) current ones.
- To create and to publish a timeline of Division responsibilities with the titles of those responsible (by Sept. 1, 2024).
- To increase membership from 53 to 75 by next summer.
- To continue e-newsletter and using Community with all officers engaged in producing content for both regularly.
Unable to reach
Future of the Division: We have been considering changes in our mission and name since 2017, when an ad hoc committee prepared a report based on results of a member survey and an analysis of Division research and programming. Division members discussed the report at length, but did not implement any recommendations. This topic was revisited occasionally and then put aside entirely during the first two years of the pandemic. In February 2022, we met virtually to restart the conversation. We held a follow-up discussion during the fall 2022 National High School Journalism Convention in St. Louis among the Division officers in attendance, and plan to discuss next steps during upcoming meetings.
DIVERSITY AND INCLUSION
In all of our solicitations for papers, panelists and awards, we tried to reach into new populations including schools with high percentages of first-year students and smaller, rural schools. We tried to reach out to get people involved in our Division that historically have not been involved but got minimal results.
RESEARCH
Did your group conduct any other type of refereed competition? No
Number of faculty research paper submissions: 20; number of accepted submissions: 13; 65% acceptance rate
Number of student research paper submissions: 9; two papers were disqualified before judging due to far exceeding the suggested length; number of accepted submissions: 2; 2/7 = 28% acceptance rate
Competition and selection process: This year, we issued our regular, broad call for full paper and extended abstract submissions on any topic related to journalism and mass communication education at all levels as well as a special topic call on how journalism educators and students are exploring AI tools within the guidelines of journalistic ethics. This special call resulted in four papers submitted on the topic of artificial intelligence in scholastic journalism classrooms. Three of these papers were accepted and bundled together for one of our four research paper sessions. Overall, using the All Academic system, the 15 papers with the highest average reviewer scores (4.64 - 3.11) were accepted. Two faculty papers and one student paper earned top paper awards. Among the faculty papers, there was a large gap between the second and third highest scores (4.55 to 4.23), thus, only two faculty papers were chosen as top papers.
Total number of judges: 17
Overview of judging process: In our Division’s newsletter, we sent a general call for reviewers in late March. All interested reviewers filled out an interest and expertise Google form, and assignments were made to align best to reviewer preferences. Each submission was assigned three reviewers from that pool, with each reviewer assigned three to four submissions. No reviewer, however, was assigned more than two full paper submissions to review. All reviewers completed their assigned reviews.
As the reviewing process was being completed, another Google Form was sent to all reviewers asking if they would like to self-nominate for moderator and/or discussant positions, along with our session times and possible topics. Eight reviewers responded. The timing of this process was problematic because several of the reviewers needed to wait for decisions on their papers before they could commit to a moderator or discussant panel time. After some back and forth communication, seven reviewers were assigned to the moderator and discussant roles. The research chair filled the final needed moderator position.
Conference research activities:
Refereed Research Paper Session Professional Roles and Resilience: Readying Young Journalists for the Work
Moderating/Presiding: Barbara Hines, Howard
- [EA] Am I a Professional? Roles of Journalism Curriculum in Identity Work of Student Journalists Vy Luong and Joy Jenkins, Missouri
- [EA] News/Academic Partnerships: Assessing the Student Experience Colleen Steffen, Franklin College and Hannah Kirkpatrick, Vermont
- [EA] Burnout Experiences Among Journalism Students, Educators, and Peripheral Actors Avery Holton and Aly Hill, Utah
- [EA] Virtually Prepared: Using VR to Build Trauma Awareness and Resilience in Journalism Students Gretchen Hoak, Kent State
- From Practice to Pedagogy: Examining Journalists as Teachers of their Profession Michael Spikes, Northwestern
Discussant: Peter Bobkowski, Kent State
Refereed Research Paper Session Developing the Future: Building Awareness of Equality Issues and Confidence in Students
Moderating/Presiding: Huixin Deng, Baldwin Wallace University
- [EA] Producing Critical Public Communicators: Assessing a First Year DEIA-Focused Media Literacy Program for Public Communications Students Charisse L’Pree Corsbie-Massay, Keonte Coleman and Rockell Brown Burton, Syracuse
- Representation of Women in Journalism Textbooks in China Haiyan Wang and Angze Li, University of Macau and Jing Meng, Peking University
- [EA] “I Don’t Know How I Would Have Done It Without Them:” International Graduate Students Pedagogical Communities of Practice within Communications Programs Ivy Ashe, Florida Atlantic and Dominique Montiel Valle, Texas at Austin
- Perception and Development of Adolescents' Algorithmic Knowledge: A Three-Dimensional Exploration Based on Digital Access, Process of Use, and Acquisitional Adoption Ding Yu, Shanghai Jiao Tong University
Discussant: Melanie Wilderman, Oklahoma
Supporting the Institutional Mission: Outreach Initiatives that Educate and Recruit High School Journalists and Communicators
Moderator: Marina Hendricks, South Dakota State
Panelists: Harrison Hove, Florida; Mark Turner, Ohio; Michelle Sillman, Iowa; Jessica Pucci (Arizona State)
Colleges and universities support an institutional mission by educating and supporting the next generation of journalists. This outreach inspires students and acts as an informal recruiting tool. The purpose of this panel is to share blueprints of successful outreach programs that can be used to support an institutional mission and recruit for your program.
Commission on Graduate Education and AEJMC Elected Standing Committee on Teaching
Scholar-to-Scholar (Poster) Refereed Research Paper Session
Scholastic Journalism Division 05-1630-09 • Perception and Development of Adolescents’ Algorithmic Knowledge: A Three-Dimensional Exploration Based on Digital Access, Process of Use, and Acquisitional Adoption Ding Yu, Shanghai Jiao Tong University
“A Good Place to Start but a Bad Place to Finish”: Current Uses and Perceptions of AI in Journalism and Media Education
Moderating/Presiding:Theresa de los Santos, Pepperdine University
- Students’ Use, Expectations, and Understanding of Generative AI Tools Aaron Veenstra, Mahalia Wright, Marcy Wilder, Fahrin Shimu, Luke Schlauder, Flavia Patino-Paul, Abigaelle Michel, Grace Macri, J.D. Johnstone, Kashine Johnson, Janna Hautala, Francesca Dousdebes, and Juliana Agamez Rosado, Florida Atlantic
- “A Starting Point and a Crutch”: Student and Faculty Perceptions of Generative AI Elia Powers, Rauf Arif, Michael Fedner, Erin Conahan, and Adaeze Ezechukwu, Towson
- [EA] Artificial Intelligence Chatbots and Social Learning Theory in the Journalism Classroom Daniel Thompson and Melanie Wilderman, Oklahoma
Discussant: Bradley Wilson, Midwestern State
Scholastic Journalism Division Top Paper Refereed Research Paper Session
Meeting Current Expectations and Needs: Responses from Journalism Educators, Young Professionals, and Audience Members
Moderating/Presiding: Serajul Bhuiyan, Savannah State
- High School Journalism Field Trips: Post-Pandemic Barriers and Opportunities* Monica Hill, North Carolina at Chapel Hill; Marina Hendricks, South Dakota State; Sarah Cavanah, Kansas; and Peter Bobkowski, Kent State
- Entering Journalism in Times of Democratic Backsliding: Hong Kong Young Journalists’ Career Decision and Persistence Tsz Fung Hans Tse, Francis Lee, and Ziqi Yang, The Chinese University of Hong Kong
- Improving the “Experience” of News Use: Toward a UX Perspective that Bridges Audience Studies in Journalism and Human-Computer Interaction** Emmanuel Maduneme, Oregon
Discussant: Elizabeth Smith, Pepperdine
* First Place Open Competition Paper Award
** First Place Graduate and Undergraduate Student Paper Award
Out-of-conference research activities:
The Division participated in the Southeast Colloquim March 7-9, 2024 at University of Kentucky in Lexington. For this regional conference, we used the overall call instead of a specific one from our DIG. We put the call for papers in our fall newsletters and solicited reviewers via a Google form in the December newsletter. We received two research-in-process submissions and one full paper submission. The four people who volunteered to serve as reviewers were either assigned the one full paper or the two extended abstracts to review. Two of the three submissions were accepted. Jennifer Greer at the University of Kentucky and her team programmed our two papers with others groups to form full sessions.
We again see solid evidence of the value of participating in a midwinter conference. The authors of the accepted full paper submission resubmitted their work to the 2024 AEJMC Conference and were accepted, becoming the Top Faculty Paper. The rejected and accepted research in progress submissions, however, did not resubmit their work to our division for the annual conference. The accepted research in progress paper was on the role of AI in educational contexts.
JEA’s Communication: Journalism Education Today published one peer-reviewed piece this academic year.
-
Cabrera, PJ. (2024). Administrative use of prior review in high school journalism programs. Communication: Journalism Education Today, 57(4), 43-50.
RESEARCH GOALS AND ACTIVITIES
Work with Journalism Education Association and other groups to increase the number of research submissions on scholastic journalism education, scholastic student media advising and other topics pertinent to the Division.
Provide better instruction or coaching for student researchers to increase their paper quality and acceptance rate.
TEACHING
Conference teaching activities:
Broadcast and Mobile Journalism and Scholastic Journalism Divisions Teaching Panel Session
Defining the Future of Journalism Education: Academia and Industry Working Together
Moderating/Presiding: Tony DeMars, Lamar
Panelists: Janet Kolodzy, Emerson; Tony DeMars, Lamar; Mia Moody-Ramirez, Baylor; Denise James, Temple; Ric Harris, NBC-10 Philadelphia
We started evolving years ago into new directions for how news is created and distributed. Some fads came and went, but the evolution continues, and we need to be as forward-thinking as possible about how to properly prepare students for media careers. This panel provides insight from academic programs and their recent-years curriculum challenges but also from a seasoned TV news professional who has seen industry changes first-hand. What are the foundational elements of journalism that must be retained, but at the same time what are the changes that must be made in training the next generation of journalists?
Newspaper and Online News and Scholastic Journalism Divisions Teaching Panel Session
Teaching News Terrifically in the 21st Century
Moderating/Presiding: Patrick Walters, Washington and Lee
Panelists: Jessica Walsh, University of Nebraska-Lincoln; Jessica James, Texas State; Newly Paul, University of North Texas; Menna Elhosary, The American University in Cairo
Teaching News Terrifically in the 21st Century has been highlighting innovative approaches to the teaching of journalism since 2009. Presented by the Newspaper and Online News and Scholastic Journalism divisions, the panel examines innovative ideas for teaching news writing, reporting, editing, or other journalistic concepts and skills in the classroom. Panelists will present on their winning teaching assignments from this year's TNT 21 competition.
Scholastic Journalism Division and Commission on Graduate Education Teaching Panel Session
Getting Curricularly Creative
Moderating/Presiding: Patrick R. Johnson, Marquette
Panelists: Nicole Kraft, Ohio State; Yayu Feng, St. Thomas; Alexis Romero Walker, Manhattanville College; Perry Parks, Michigan State; Greg Hoplamazian, Loyola Maryland; Jasun Carr, Idaho State
This panel will focus on varied approaches to developing a curriculum that is both responsive to moments and changes and sustainable to keep faculty workloads manageable. Panelists will share the different ways they tackle curriculum design and their tips and tricks for being innovative.
Commission on Graduate Education and Scholastic Journalism Division
Teaching Panel Session
Chatting ChatGPT: Ethical Use of AI in Research and Pedagogy
Moderating/Presiding: Briana Trifiro, Boston
Panelists: Kate Mays, Vermont; Jared Schroeder, Missouri; Laura K. Smith, South Carolina; Bradley Wilson, Midwestern State; Fan Yang, South Florida
This panel will introduce attendees to a number of emerging AI platforms that can help scholars at all career stages to conduct research more diligently and effectively, from conducting thorough literature reviews to formatting a manuscript to journal specifications, as well as offer solutions for ways in which instructors can integrate technology and AI in the classroom in innovative, productive, and above all – ethical – ways.
Out-of-conference teaching activities: Generally, members of this division are involved in a number of activities to support scholastic journalism widely.
- Bradley Wilson, division chair, is editor of the national magazine of the Journalism Education Association — Communication: Journalism Education Today — and actively recruits peer-reviewed submissions for the magazine. https://jea.org/wp/home/for-educators/cjet/
- RJ Morgan, vice chair, is director of the Mississippi Scholastic Journalism Association, a position he has held since 2013. He launched the Integrated Marketing Communication Association, a national high school media/marketing organization housed at the University of Mississippi.
- Elizabeth Smith, the teaching chair of this division is president of the board for the National Scholastic Press Association/Associated Collegiate Press. As part of her work, she helps to plan three national conventions and workshops that serve middle and high school journalism students and advisers. She also spent four days in Minneapolis, Minnesota, at a summit with staff and executive committee from the Journalism Education Association working to rethink and reimagine high school journalism programming, including the national conferences. Additionally in this role, Elizabeth works closely with the Society of Professional Journalists and College Media Association on initiatives related to teaching and learning. In this area, Elixabeth began this school year working to be more intentional about coordinating with Sarah Cavanah to highlight teaching efforts in the division newsletter. Sarah was diligent about reaching out for this to happen. The idea with this is to create more of a sense of pedagogical community and more communication among the members of the division around teaching.
- Theresa de los Santos, research chair, also serves on the AEJMC elected Standing Committee on Teaching and leads conference workshops on teaching activities.
Teaching goals and activities:
- To assist with ensuring a 2025 Teach-in for the annual AEJMC Conference in San Francisco. This is a critical component to support scholastic journalism, particularly in the regions of the annual conference.
- To coordinate with middle and high school journalism teachers local to the Philadelphia area virtually throughout the coming school year..
- To feature a teaching section in the division newsletter each time it is published. Following the conference, we can highlight key takeaways from the SJD panel presentations.
- To coordinate more sessions across divisions that focus on pedagogy and teaching.
PROFESSIONAL FREEDOM AND RESPONSIBILITY
Conference PF&R activities:
Scholastic Journalism Division and Commission on the Status of Minorities
PFR Panel Session
Implementing Diversity in the J-School Newsroom: Part II
Moderating/Presiding: Jesús Ayala, California State, Long Beach
Panelists: Keonte Coleman, Syracuse Celeste Gonzalez de Bustamante, Texas at Austin Rachel Grant, Florida Nathian Rodriguez, San Diego State
Building on previous sessions regarding diversity, equity and inclusion in journalism school newsrooms, come learn from fellow educators and newsroom advisers who have successfully taught how to build cultural competency to diversify news coverage.
Newspaper and Online News and Scholastic Journalism Divisions
PFR Panel Session
Champions of Editing
Moderating/Presiding: Mitch McKenney, Kent State
Featured speaker: Ross Maghielse, deputy managing editor for innovation & development, Philadelphia Inquirer
This annual gathering is open to anyone who teaches editing, appreciates editing or simply likes to hang around editing professors. This year's speaker, Ross Maghielse, helps shape audience growth, innovation, business and content strategy at The Philadelphia Inquirer. He previously worked for The Guardian, CBS Local Digital Media, Facebook, Bleacher Report and Digital First Media's Project Thunderdome. Ross also plays a lead role in recruitment, retention and staff development for the Inquirer newsroom, so he'll also have advice on how students can best prepare themselves and present their work. Additionally, winners of the Linda Shockley Award for Excellence in Teaching will share their ideas for teaching editing. Special thanks go to our financial sponsors: the Dow Jones News Fund, ACES: The Society for Editing, and The Poynter Institute.
PF&R goals and activities: It has been a challenging semester (not quite a year) for the student press, especially at the college/university level as students had to cover various protests including those of the Israel/Humas conflict often making national news.
- The Value of Student Journalism Has Never Been Clearer — https://nbcuacademy.com/campus-protests-student-journalism/
- Student journalists are covering their own campuses in convulsion. Here’s what they have to say — https://apnews.com/article/campus-protests-student-journalists-b9ff00a494cdb69d45bd1f99db28288b
- Covering Columbia’s Student Protests Gave Me Hope About Journalism’s Future — https://time.com/6976426/columbia-protests-journalism-essay/
The good news on the scholastic side is the addition of New Voices states, with Minnesota being the 18th, as of May 2024. There are proposals in nine other states at various stages of the legislative process.
In the courthouse, Antonelli v. Hammond was a good moment for student press freedom, as the student newspaper (The Cycle) editor successfully sued the president of Fitchburg State College. Court would not allow prior review.
We need to start thinking, especially in the South, about these state laws that will allow cameras to record us teaching and what this might mean for instruction in the journalism classroom.
GENERAL INFORMATION
Awards: Members of the Scholastic Journalism Division selected four individuals as recipients of the Division's 2024 recognition:
- Honors Lecture: Vincent Filak
- David Adams Scholastic Journalism Division Educator of the Year: Marina Hendricks
- Robert Knight Multicultural Recruitment Award: Melanie Wilderman
- Innovative Outreach to Scholastic Journalism Award: Monica Hill
Recognition: The Journalism Education Association named Candace Perkins Bowen, John Bowen and Mark Goodman as three of the nine recipients of the Lifetime Achievement Award. All three were active in the Scholastic Journalism Division of AEJMC.
Community: Our Community site is basically working but we’re all still learning how to update it and haven’t figured out some aspects of maintenance of the site.
Newsletter: Following a goal set by SJD in 22-23, the division restarted a monthly e-newsletter for Division members and others interested in the work of the Division. The first edition came out Friday, Oct. 6, 2023. Editions have come out the first Friday of the month since then, along with a few special editions for time-sensitive information. In all, 12 editions and special notices have been sent out. The original mailing list in October 2023 included 79 recipients. Since then, one person has asked to be unsubscribed and 20 have been added to the list or have joined the Division. On average, the newsletter has a 61.3% open rate. The current subscriber list includes 98 individual addresses. Information for the newsletter comes from AEJMC notices, officer-created items and submissions to a news tip form. Information from the newsletter is either directly entered or linked on the AEJMC Community site.
Center of Scholastic Journalism: Peter Bobkowski joined the School of Media and Journalism in the fall as Kent State University’s second Knight Chair in Scholastic Journalism, dedicated to leading national efforts to revitalize journalism in the nation's high schools. Kent’s Center of Scholastic Journalism, offers a master's degree with a focus on scholastic journalism and provides the most comprehensive census of high school journalism programs in the country. Mark Goodman was the first Kent State Knight Chair. Candace Perkins Bowen previously directed the Center of Scholastic Journalism.